I’ve been meaning to review my Mansur Gavriel Bucket bag for quite a while now, and after carrying it for the past month straight, I am ready to give you an in-depth look at this sought-after bag. I received this bag as a gift from the brand and was beyond ecstatic to get my hands on this gem. The color, Rosa, exudes femininity, and the bag itself has become the anti-It Bag It Bag.
Check out how my Mansur Gavriel Bucket Bag scores in our Purseonals below!
Aesthetics 
The Mansur Gavriel Bucket Bag gets a 5 out of 5 stars for aesthetics. The bucket bag shape was not reinvented by the brand’s design duo, but consumer adoration for this shape came back full force when Mansur Gavriel released this bag. Since then, countless brands have added bucket bags to their roster, and while many are beautiful, the Mansur Gavriel option is the most recognizable.
The color on this bag is another wow factor for me. The black with red interior is one of the most sought-after combos, but I think the Rosa pink is the prettiest option out there. I have been told by countless people how beautiful my bag is when I carry it. It’s gotten almost out of control how many compliments this bag gets, and at one point, I thought someone was complimenting me, but they were really complimenting my bag.
There isn’t a ton you can say about the design because it is exactly what you think of when you think of a bucket bag. It closes with a drawstring, and the leather Mansur Gavriel uses holds its shape well, which makes this bag even easier to spot.
Usability + Functionality 
For me, a bucket bag is much like a bottomless pit. The tall body of the bag (mine is the large size; Mansur now offers a Mini and Mini Mini option) makes the interior roomy, but I can never quite find what I’m looking for. When I reach my hand into the bag, I pull out everything other than what I want. My lipgloss is always hidden, my phone seems to be eaten by the interior, and there’s a lot of digging without actually finding what I’m looking for.
The bag does offer a snap-on skinny pouch on the interior of the bag, which you could take out and use separately. I actually haven’t used this pouch yet, but I could start putting my lipgloss inside and see if that helps me find hard-to-hunt-down small items.
The drawstring top of the bag is not an easy open/close; it’s self-tie, which can also make it harder to open and expand on demand.
One of the upsides of the usability is the adjustable shoulder strap. I wear the bag long enough that when the bag is on my shoulder, I can easily reach down to get something in and out of my bag. My wallet and pouch are super easy to find, and I love how long the strap can get, especially for someone as tall as me.
Quality + Construction 
I was really interested to see how this bag would hold up with use. The color is, of course, worrisome, but I can report that even with the light pink color, this bag is holding up magnificently. I am quite surprised, to be honest–not that I thought it would fall apart, but I expected the leather to start to scratch and colors to transfer onto my bag much more easily.
My bag has a coated calf finish, and it has stood the test of extreme use. When I start using a bag on a daily basis, I really use it. I take it to the gym and put it on the floor (I know, the horror!), pit it in my shopping cart at the grocery store, put it on tables and seats. This bag only shows a bit of wear on the bottom corners and a slight scratch in one spot, but otherwise has remained fresh and clean.
The leather was much more structured than I anticipated, but that has ended up being something I love about the bag. The shape that gives the style remains and the top shows the waves of the drawstring top which appears really beautiful when you look at it.
Mansur also offers vegetable tanned leather and tumbled leather; the vegetable tanned shows wear a bit more (I’ve seen Amanda’s black with red interior, and it looks much more worn than this bag does), and I’m sure the tumbled leather only gets nicer with wear. I’m a big fan of the coated calf finish; it keeps the bag looking lovely.
My bag has been rained on, had things spilled on it, and really been used for well over a month now, and it still looks close to brand new.
Value 
My bag costs $695, and that is an amazing price. Other contemporary designers at this price point are not making their bags in Italy, and for many of them, the quality is sub-par, to say the least. Mansur Gavriel will be a price hike in the near future, but the bags still remain a very good value and price point.
The coated calf finish is the most expensive; the tumbled leather is $625, vegetable tanned leather is $495 and the canvas and leather combo is $445.
Staying Power 
A very simple design and concept tends to have the most staying power when it comes to a relatively new designer. We know the likes of the Louis Vuitton Speedy and Chanel Reissue will always stand the test of the time, but with a newer brand, you want to look for the lines of the design. A bucket bag will always be a staple in the handbag world, and because of that, this bag may not always be at this constantly sold-out height of the bag market, but it will not fall into obscurity.
Total 
The Mansur Gavriel Bucket Bag gets 4.3 stars in our Purseonals ratings. If it weren’t for the usability and functionality, the bag would score much higher, as each other category scores near perfect, if not perfect. I liked this bag when I first saw it but didn’t always get the hype, but when I got one for myself, I ended up learning to love it more than I expected. It’s easy to wear, looks great, and the price is hard to beat, especially when other major designers are upping their prices by 10% a year.
Stay tuned to PurseBlog to figure out how to get your hands on one of these bags for yourself–we always try to let you know when they become available!
I love the bag, and your shoes are so fab.
They’re Schutz! They made me well over 6’3 but look awesome!
Do you remember the style name? I looked online and I don’t see them! Must have!!
I’ll try to figure it out!
I have 3! Love it! I find that if I store items in small leather accessories (wallet, cosmetic pouch-I use 2, eyeglass case, etc…) things are much easier to find. I also don’t cinch it completely close unless I’m riding public transportation. I otherwise leave a big enough gap to get my hand in and out easily.
I have been trying that too! I don’t pull it too tight, but I think any bag with this design is harder to get in and out of to find things.
It is not as easy as my other bags that’s for sure, but it is also one of my more lighter bags. I also like that you can carry a lot without looking like you have some massive sack on your shoulder. Seeing the pink I might have to think about that one too!
Although I’m not a fan of bucket bags for myself, it looks good on you. Plus, I’m impressed you can even walk in those shoes!
Not going to lie, I can’t walk far in those shoes…!
I do not understand the popularity of this bag. I guess that goes to show that you neve know what will become uber popular. The price point is nice and that may be the attraction. It is basic and a little boring but if they gave me one I would probably use it.
I agree. We already wore it in the past time (already seen!) and the bucket bag was famous to be a very unpractical bag (as Megs says she can’t find what she is looking for…) and very easy to get inside for a thief, the leather is for us in Italy a very common one, the line not really original…a little boring, sorry
I feel the same. It’s basic, functional and not offensive. So if given one, I’d put it in rotation. But I don’t get the mania.
This bag is like the LV bucket bag with the epi leather, a bag that’s hard to use for everyday purposes.
I agree you have made this bag look cooler than I’ve ever seen! It looks awesome on you. I still don’t understand bucket bags they ARE like bottomless pits! But I just bought a Falabella and love it so maybe I’m coming around to the less structured look.
Very helpful review! Thank you!
I’ve had 1 bucket bag (Cole Haan) and never again, though your shoes are super cool–envy envy! (I would be on the ground with broken ankles)
Give me a Tote in THIS color and I will give you (mansur gavriel) my money.
I have their black and red medium bucket back which i have not used yet. But i see the usability point Megs. not functional enough. The bucket bags will be for those quick short trips to the mall or grocery store or outings, not for everyday use.
Hope you guys would donate to the earthquake victims in Nepal. I am from Nepal and the people need our help to rebuild and rehabilitate. Thank you.
I have the tote in this color, and I’m not such a fan. In the tote bag, I just feel like my stuff is always sliding around inside which I don’t love. :/
Can’t wait to get my hands on one of these.. As for the price increase, do we know when this will most likely be? Really hoping it stays under the 600 mark! This will be my first “real” designer bag.
I have four of the bucket bags. Just got the black with the bright blue interior. I absolutely love them. I do find that I keep all my items in pouches, however, in order to put my hands on them. I ordered the canvas/leather combo from Moda Operandi, which photographed much brighter than what I received, so I returned it immediately. I am waiting for the Lady bag to come out in pink. It is in the $1,100.00 range. It looks fantastic.
amazing photos! what type of camera does vlad use?
Thank you! Here I used a Fuji X-T1 with a 56mm f/1.2 lens.
He has so many cameras, don’t remember which one he used for this, but I’m sure he will add his comments
The bag and yourself look absolutely fab! This is one of those effortlessly chic bags that look equally well with jeans or a cocktail dress. In slide 5 when you are tossing the bucket up-that was a clear indication to me of your phrase “put the bag to GOOD use” I would never dream of tossing my bags????
I don’t have the patience to hound pre sales or flash mobs so I will wait until the hype dies down and I can purchase the bag like a normal human being. Do you think that will happen in our lifetime?!
Thanks! Ya, I think it will die down – brands that have such a huge success may continue with the success, but the constantly sold-out status is one that will not continue forever if history is a predictor.
I have this in the original black and red combination, and I love it. I was originally worried about how delicate the (vegetable tanned, I think) leather would be, but it’s sturdier than it looks. Mine has some minor scuffs and scratches, especially around the parts that get handled the most (where the knot of the tie hits, for example). But it’s in a lot better shape than I thought it would be.
While it does have the tendency to be a bottomless pit, the red interior of mine really helps me find what I need. Although I made the mistake of using an iPhone case in the exact same shade, making my phone practically invisible. The pouches help A LOT, allowing me to pull out what I need without having to look.
I’ve been reading purseblog for 5 years and this is my first comment ever :D. This bag is beyond beautiful. The color is something else. I have the black/flamma, but it doesn’t take my breath away like the pink one does. BTW, love the couch xx!
Thanks for reading and commenting! The pink color is really pretty. And the couch is new, I really love it too!
Those shoes are the business! The Mansur bucket bag is nice but I can easily pass.
People are really liking the shoes! I can’t remember the name, I’ve had them for a few years now
The other ratings don’t average out to 4.3, and the stars graphic for the total looks more like 3.5.
Ahh, the 4.5 star is not working for some reason and showing as a 3.5. The other categories are supposed to be 4.5 that show as 3.5! Thank you for pointing this out!!!
Something must be off, let me fix it (which other ratings don’t average?)
Has anyone heard of ‘ghibli’? I can only see their bags at forzieri.com
That shade of pink is so beautiful, classy, and timeless. However, I absolutely detest bucket bags, and will never understand why they are ever in vogue. They are not practical, and remind me of something a child would carry.
Looks FANTASTIC! You choose the best color !!! 🙂
That was also my biggest issue with any bucket bag is the functionality. I love the look, but everything settles at the bottom.
I adore the color. Very soft and pretty.
< col Hiiiiiii Friends….uptil I saw the paycheck saying $8736 , I have faith that my neighbour woz actualy receiving money parttime from their computer. . there friends cousin has done this 4 only about thirteen months and by now repaid the loans on there mini mansion and got a great GMC . visit their website SEE FULL DETAIL
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1
I only had one bucket bag ever and swore never to buy another one again because of the inconvenience. This and other brands’ bucket bags are nice (great colors/style variations) but they have not changed my mind. I hate the close/open tie and it’s really like a garbage bag – you throw everything in and hate to take anything out.
Megs could you please tell me the name of the book in the last picture, I’m curious and I can’t figure it out. BTW you look gorgeous in the second slide
I have the black/flamma and it’s starting to show some wear (i’ve had it since july 2014), the scratches really show against the black finish. Bt i still love it! The bottom is still in a good shape but i have to agree with you, it’s basically a black hole. All in all, I’m still obsessed with it and want to get a second one, but shipping & duty fees are just ridiculous (I live in Montreal, Canada).
< col Hiiiiiii Friends….uptil I saw the receipt for $6027 , I be certain …that…my friend woz like truly erning money part time from there labtop. . there sisters roommate has done this for only twenty one months and by now repaid the debts on their mini mansion and purchased a top of the range Citroën DS . More Info SEE FULL DETAIL
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~b
Thanks Megs for the in dept review! I just bought the black flamma bucket bag for my birthday and I love it! But this light pink colour is also to die for. I’m too surprised how this bag looks after a month of use. I carry my macbook, grocery’s and a lot of other stuff with me and it still looks brand new. The online downside of this bag is dat the details are sloppy. I can see the markings of the sewing machine on ALL the edges.
i had the black flamma since Dec 2013, it was popular back then (apparently hubby refreshed the net-a-porter site countless time a day before xmas) but not as crazy as today. I don’t mind the bottomless pit hole as I carry minimal and easily identifiable things but what drives me crazy is the obvious scratches and some white patches the bag gets due to wear and tear. It is no longer the sleek black it was once (though I still get tons of compliments), and for this reason I don’t think I’ll buy another MG unless the colour takes my breath away like this one…damn you purseblog!
Thanks for the review Megs! I used a different bucket bag today and it made me crazy! The bag is stunning, but if I decide I can’t resist, I’ll be opting for the $99 Zara version.
Please help me! I want to buy a Mansur bag. I save money every year to buy a good bag
for my birthday. I already bought a couple of LV, one Prada Saffiano
leather tote and one Fendi petit 2 jours. I don’t use the Prada too
much because it turns out to be an heavy bag and although it has a
shoulder strap it doesn’t look that good when I wear it on my shoulder. The one I wear the most is my
Fendi. I use the shoulder strap every day because I have to carry all my books
to college and if I want to go out at night I take out the strap and it becomes
the cutest chic bag ever. I told you my mini collection of bags and now
I need help to decide if I should buy a Mansur Gavriel or
not.. It’s a bad thing not to be able to touch and try the bag before buy
it.. And I’m 1,67 cm (5,7) so i don’t know if the shoulder strap is too
big for me.. And as i wear the bags every day to college I don’t know if
the leather will become ugly with time. On the other hand it has a good
price compared to Prada and Fendi. It’s a beautiful bag too. Please help me!
What do you think I should do? (and i’m sorry for my bad English)
Awesome post! Do you have any experience with the Dooney & Bourke Alto Sophia? I’d love to know how they compare. I Gavriel is HOT!!, but that tote strap on the Dooney seems a lot more versatile. What do you think?
I don’t ike this style of bag, but the bag is really good. They did great job!
Love yours! I just got the bucket bag in light tan (Carmella) and after wearing it once, my jeans (which have been washed 100 times) have worn into the leather! Any advice? Has this happened to you and does it wipe clean easily? Thanks!
i have this same problem with my rosa mini! did you figure how to get it out/what did you end up doing about it? i don’t want to stop wearing my jeans that transfer on them as they are the only jeans that fit me extremely well!
I really love this bag, i bought it in a mini & to my horror my jeans (black denim) transferred a little bit. This is my first expensive bag, how do i avoid this? i had to come home & switch bags to my sturdy kate spade because i didn’t want to risk it esp while i was out having drinks..a lot of drinks
nvm! i figured out how to with gentle stuff i already have : )
Hi! Great post. Could you tell me if the sides of this bag where the leather sort of folds (due to pulling the drawstring closed) and shows wrinkles?
Thank you!!
Great post! (as always)