In a criticism class that I took in college (yes, journalism school includes instruction on being effectively judgmental), we were taught that the best way to review anything is to decide what the artistic goals of the person who created it were, and then evaluate how well those goals were met. That way, the personal taste of the critic takes a back seat to the objective success of the person who created the work, and I shall try to do just that while writing about Herve Leger Fall 2011.

The prospect of reviewing a collection of bandage dresses was a bit puzzling even before the collection debuted earlier today, because it’s sort of like trying to establish the relative merits of your mom’s Thanksgiving turkey – you knew what was coming, you knew what it was going to taste like and getting anything different would have completely collapsed your worldview as you know it. Herve Leger means bandage dresses, whether you like it or not.

And bandage dresses were exactly what we got, in varying lengths and neutral colors, some covered with hardware and others relatively bare. The collection didn’t feel new, but it did feel like the kind of clothing that lots of women will want to wear when they want to go out at night and look hot. The evening gowns in particular were an unexpected highlight; hopefully the brand will explore more opportunities in that silhouette in the future.

Photos via the New York Times.

P.S. Please consider supporting our small, bag-loving team by clicking our links before shopping or checking out at your favorite online retailers like Amazon, Neiman Marcus, Nordstrom, or any of the listed partners on our shop page. We truly appreciate your support!

Share Your Thoughts With Us

  • Merve

    Tried and tested everybody loved the bandage and now they are trying to be as creative with it as they can until people start saying another bandage??? yawn. The dresses are really wearable which is always a good thing but whether i can tell it apart from Fall 2010 is another story.

  • Jane H.

    Are my eyes deceiving me or have those photos been a bit… stretched?

  • MizzJ

    I think it’s interesting how they keep trying to reinvent the bandage. It’s kinda like how Lagerfeld reinvents tweed jackets every season. I do wish though that they wouldn’t do their _entire_ collection based around bandage dresses though. It’s all very nice, but always always the same thing.

  • shueaddict

    I only wore a HL bandage dress once (after a few months of starvation and gym overkill) – only to prove that I have the guts to wear it. Now I just hiss at it in my closet