Despite the fact that yesterday was the hottest day of 2014 so far in New York City, we are now post-Labor Day, which means it’s our duty, as fashion writers, to push both you and ourselves as quickly into fall dressing as humanly possible. What better way to do that than with fur? Specifically, we’re going to examine these two fur bucket bags in our latest edition of The Look for Less.

Fur is one of those situations where the quality of material used is immediately apparent, and that means it’s not terribly difficult to figure out that the Ralph Lauren Shearling Bucket Bag is the more expensive option here. I’d love to own a pillow made out of this bag’s fur, but based on the price of the bag, that’s not an option.

The Elizabeth & James bag is similar in both color and structure, but the fur used is different. Not only is this kind of curly lamb less expensive, but it has a less precious look to it; this is a decidedly casual bag that adds texture to an outfit without overpowering the other pieces, while the Ralph Lauren version is definitely a statement piece unto itself. The prices certain reflect those aesthetic differences.

Which do you like better? Is the Ralph Lauren version worth the nearly $4,000 price difference?

Elizabeth & James Cynnie Lamb Fur Sling Bag
$795 via Neiman Marcus

Elizabeth and James Cynnie Lamb Fur Sling Bag

Ralph Lauren Shearling Bucket Bag
$4,500 via Neiman Marcus

Ralph Lauren Shearling Fur Bucket Bag

P.S. Please consider supporting our small, bag-loving team by clicking our links before shopping or checking out at your favorite online retailers like Amazon, Neiman Marcus, Nordstrom, or any of the listed partners on our shop page. We truly appreciate your support!

Share Your Thoughts With Us

  • Rosa Lily

    Not sure about the E & J bag. I just visualized a dog’s head popping out if I unzip it. Like the RL more, wish it were faux though.

  • Oh wow! The Ralph Lauren bag is something else entirely. I absolutely love it :)

  • Khaya

    The RL version is CLEARLY better, regardless of price. I love the luxuriousness of the fur on it! The other one just looks gross.

  • louch

    There is a clear difference between the two online – the RL looks far superior. I would imagine IRL the E&J would look even cheaper. No brainer