Has Social Media Taken the Luster Out of Fashion?

The element of surprise has been replaced with a 'share everything all the time' mentality

The art of the fashion presentation has changed dramatically over time, but the modern day fashion show dates back to the mid 1800s. According to CNN, it was English designer Charles Frederick Worth who first used live models instead of mannequins to show his designs in Paris. Soon after, small scale events known as “fashion parades” began happening in other cities like London and New York.

Unlike the media frenzy that fashion shows have become today, in history, most fashion shows were private events that often did not allow the use of photography out of fear that the designs would be copied. Also much unlike the fashion show as we know it today, the focus of such productions used to be on the client, not the media, as designers would often sell directly to customers.

That all began to shift in the late 1940’s, when Christian Dior became one of the first designers to allow photographers to photograph his collection. However the practice would not become commonplace for quite sometime.

In fact, it wasn’t until the 1970s that the fashion show became what we know it as in modern time, when ready-to-wear really began to take precedence over haute couture and the runway became the new way for designers’ to show collections. And over time, the fashion show evolved into the massive production that it is today, bringing the show to the masses but at what cost?

Gone are the days of waiting to to receive your copy of the New York Times or Women’s Wear Daily (and then eventually of logging onto Vogue Runway as collections hit the screen) to read reviews and view images of designers’ newest collections. These days the possibilities are endless, with livestreams on social media to designers dropping photographic hints at what bags are being shown in an upcoming collection, there are no surprises anymore.

While the industry has worked hard to feel less elusive and more inclusive (and rightfully so), there’s something to be said about an air of mystery. For those who grew up on the cusp of Y2K, it was that magical unknown world that drew many of us in and left us clamoring to feel part of something.

These days the mystique has been traded for the share everything all the time mentality, but truth be told, I miss the element of surprise. I miss that butterfly feeling in the pit of my stomach upon seeing that one collection a season that blew away all the others.

While fashion is changing, in a lot of ways for the better, I wish more designers would hold things a little closer to the vest. And in a world where we always want more, in this case maybe we’re better off with less.

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Stay up-to-date in the world of bags, delivered straight to your inbox.

By clicking Subscribe, you acknowledge our Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime via the link in every email.

guest

16 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
kayley

most purses don’t excite me anymore. They are overexposed by all the “influencers” who seem to have gotten the purses as PR samples but try so hard to make it sound like they genuinely love it only to sneakily sell them on secondhand websites for a thumping amount. I see this with Senreve, Bulgari etc so much that the first thing I do is check if it is sponsored and then switch off. This is why I get excited when you guys introduce little known brands who make beautiful purses untainted by the greedy make money fast influences like Lydia Millen, Fashion Mumblr, In the Frow and Shea Whitney to name a few.

AmyG

The worst offenders of all:
Stella Connolly (the worst!)
Isabelle’s Style
Mel in Melbourne

Unboxing > mini review > what’s in my bag > vlog sale > bags I sold and why

The formula just repeats over and over again. Luxury fashion has become fast fashion.

Nana

I agree. I love Stella, I’ve been a subbie on her FA channel since she had less than 2500 subbies, but her spending habits have gone a bit crazy lately. I don’t think she thinks about her purchases at all from a practical point of view – she buys 4000 dollar bags like a kid buys lollipops, wears the bags once, twice or never and then sells them. The bags she ends up selling are mostly special editions and seasonal pieces, but she always gravitates towards her basic bags like Chanel classic flaps, LV Nano Speedy and Palm Springs mini.
We’ll see how many times she will use the Birkin she will inevitably buy, before she sells it.

AmyG

Stella literally buys pieces she clearly doesn’t like, don’t suit her and then asks her viewers if she should keep the bag. It’s so sad, people can see through you when you’re not being true to yourself! I love her personality, she is a Ray of sunshine and such a positive spirit, I wish she’d stick to buying what she actually loves and speak to the bags that she actually uses. I don’t need to constantly be bombarded with new releases !

psny15

Please add these fake phony influcers to the list:
tamara kalinic
Claire chanelle
Jerusha closet
Maria dragonova
Lvlovercc
Mel in Melbourne

Amazona

Oh. I thought I was the only one who had a problem with all of the mentioned influencers…I’ve watched (or tried to watch) one video from all of them and got a weird vibe. Like they are either addicted to shopping or getting all their stuff for free and that’s why they are pushing the idea of owning them so furiously. Plus they have so much stuff already, before getting new s**t in their closets it makes me anxious. It’s just not right. Glad to see I’m not alone in this!

psny15

I couldn’t agree more with you, also these individuals have no where to wear these outfits and bags except to the shops to go buy more of these outfits and shops! I hope young people and their content don’t think this is normal because this is absolutely abnormal – they get stuff for free and then sell it so that’s a revenue stream for their in addition to their YouTube and IG ad revenue

kayley

LOL yes, I stopped watching all their content. It is ridiculous how often these influencers do massive luxury hauls only to proclaim in 1 month that they are becoming sustainable and minimalist to only declutter the entire closet and haul again. The cycle is painful to watch and kills all my joy about luxury goods.

Lori

I still read Vogue and love to see the fashions there. I don’t follow many “influencers” on IG mostly because I find them so contrived and disingenuous. Their posts are actually humorous to me which may be because I am over 50 and bitter, LOL. But either way, I do agree with your article, it’s like the good news and the bad news…all in one. We get to see everything which is great, but it takes away from the fun of stumbling across something fabulous by mistake.

ILP

I completely agree with you. Social media has killed mystery…from getting to know a new romantic interest, to celebrity personalities (who often disappoint) to over saturation of high fashion items. We see and read and know about everything instantly. I miss the days of the slow reveal.

Mary T.

I don’t mind seeing bags online, etc. because it lets me know immediately if it’s a bag that can work for me.

FashionableLena

I like to look at social media for inspiration. At my age, I’m not easily swayed. I don’t need mystery in fashion. Just show me what you have.

parrisnotfrance

I agree. When I was younger, I loved finding out about new fashion campaigns by flipping through W magazine. I also loved learning about new items in various fashion spreads. Nowadays what I dislike about fashion is you can feel the pressure of the marketing push and you can feel/experience everything in real time. I understand that nostalgic feeling of experiencing new things at your own pace with traditional methods of media (newspapers & magazines, etc.). Of course fashion has always been a business, but now it seems less about the art and more about the sale.

psny15

Yes, social media and so called influencers (ig and YouTube stars) have completely killed the joy of discovery of new styles of bags and clothes. I enjoyed watching an item in a magazine, newspaper or TV show and trying to figure out what a bag is but now it’s blatantly pushed onto me. I recall recently Polene and senrev sent many free bags to everyone and their mother and everyone was saying how great they are lol, happened with the Bvlgari sepenti bag and also fendi by the way bag, and let’s not forget the bv pouch! I understand fashion is a business but these influencers do a review and the bag is on realreal or rebag in like two weeks! Young people fall into the trap of wanting these so called “it bags” and creating the idea of a seasonal “wish list” of junk they don’t need or use in 3 to 5 years!! YouTube and IG is definitely on the decline in my opinion but I can’t wait for the new Era of fashion

Sandy

I like seeing what’s new prior to the new season. I keep track of the things that sing to me and pick a few every season to purchase. Bags are a bit different however, if I like a bag I wait and see if it appears there will be longevity. Bags are too expensive to buy impulsively. I cannot justify buying multiple bags in a year, at times there are a few years between purchases.

Jaime

I read Apple News Fashion articles to get that feeling of excitement and trends. Social Media is overwhelming with fashion that is not really fashion but with how odd can I dress. I still have subscriptions to Bazaar, Town and Country, InStyle to just have that break from social media.

You May Also Like