PurseBlog Beauty: 10 Mascaras to Try This Fall

Seasonal transitions are a good time to change things up, whether that means ordering a new leather jacket, sorting through a box of last year’s sweaters or deciding what works and what doesn’t in your current beauty routine. In that spirit, we’ve been scoping out some of the season’s best bets in different makeup categories, and today, we’re here to talk about mascara.

We’ve done some research on mascara and its related products, and below, you can check out the fruits of our labor if you’re in the need of a little lash pick-me-up. (And really, aren’t we all?)

Anastasia Beverly Hills Lash Genius Waterproof Topcoat
$21 via Macy’s

If you have a mascara you already love but you wish had a little more staying power or that you could wear it during temperamental weather, this is the thing to get (and it actually works)!

Anastasia-Beverly-Hills-Lash-Genius-Waterproof-Topcoat

Chanel Inimitable Waterproof Mascara
$32 via Chanel

If you’re a longtime PurseBlog reader, you’ve probably seen me sing this stuff’s praises before; I’ve probably bought a dozen tubes of it in my life, if not more. It lengthens, separates and volumizes wonderfully.

Chanel-Inimitable-Waterproof-Mascara

Chantecaille Faux Cils Longest Lash Mascara
$70 via Nordstrom

This stuff is super pricey, and whether or not it’s worth it probably depends on how much $70 and/or your eyelashes are worth to you. It’s the only thing that ever lured me away from my Chanel holy grail, though.

Chantecaille-Faux-Cils-Longest-Lash-Mascara

Clinique Bottom Lash Mascara
$10.50 via Macy’s

Did you know bottom-lash mascara was an actual thing? It is, and if your regular mascara makes a muddy mess out of the area below your eyes, this is the stuff you need to try.

Clinique-Bottom-Lash-Mascara

Estée Lauder Sumptuously Extreme Waterproof Volume Mascara
$26 via Macy’s

This is one of the most beloved mascaras on the market, especially if you’re looking to pump up thin lashes.

Estee-Lauder-Sumptuously-Extreme-Waterproof-Volume-Mascara

Guerlain Maxilash Intense Volumizing Mascara
$30 via Sephora

Although “volume” is in the name, this mascara is widely beloved for both curling and lengthening as well.

Guerlain-Maxilash-Intense-Volumizing-Mascara

Lancôme Definicils High Definition Mascara
$27.50 via Macy’s

This is one of the most popular mascaras in the world and has been for ages. It is not without reason–Definicils was the first formula I used that convinced me mascara was a thing worth wearing.

Lancom-Definicils-High-Definition-Mascara

NARS Audacious Mascara
$26 via Sephora

This is a new mascara that’s gotten somewhat mixed reviews, but I have some friends who are absolutely, totally in love with it, and it’s definitely the next one I’m going to try.

NARS-Audacious-Mascara

Peter Thomas Roth Lashes to Die For The Mascara
$22 via Macy’s

No clumps, no smudges and plenty of ingredients to nourish your lashes over time.

Peter-Thomas-Roth-Lashes-To-Die-For-The-Mascara

Shiseido Nourishing Mascara Base
$24 via Macy’s

Speaking of nourishing: this base coat really, really works.

Shiseido-Nourishing-Mascara-Base

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Stay up-to-date in the world of bags, delivered straight to your inbox.

By clicking Subscribe, you acknowledge our Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime via the link in every email.

guest

7 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Amazona

For an organic luxury alternative: Kjaer Weis. For $38, it’s a great deal, safe for you and the environment. The packaging is refillable, as are all Kjaer Weis.

By Marlie

Thank you for including mascaras in all price ranges! Sometimes, I just don’t feel like using my $50 mascara on a daily basis on the account of I feel like I’m wasting it.

http://www.bymarlie.wordpress.com

Immodest Goddess

Nothing will ever compare to the perfection that was Lash Stylist. All these years after, I’m still in mourning

anon

Would you guys ever do a drugstore makeup related post? It’s totally fine if you keep posting about higher end makeup, but I think a post like that would be great and relate to a lot of other people besides me:P

Amanda Mull

Of course! That’s a great idea, in fact.

Passerine

Thanks for these! I’ve been disappointed with my last few expensive mascaras and my two favorites, esp Clinique’s old Gentle Waterproof Mascara, have been discontinued. I really miss the Clinique one. It was perfect for everyday wear.

I checked these on makeupalley and the reviews are pretty mixed. The Chantecaille mascara fares the best with the MA reviewers, so I will give that one a try.

If I can add one option in the lower price range, it’s Mavala (of Switzerland) Eye-Lite Waterproof. Friends have it and rave about it. And it costs about $10 a tube. However, it can be difficult to find. I’m going to look for it this week and try it.

http://www.makeupalley.com/product/showreview.asp/ItemId=60271/Eye-Lite-Waterpoof/Mavala/Mascara

SleepyGirl

Chantecaille has two non-waterproof mascaras… the one above for $70 and a less expensive version (without the lengthening formula) for $40. The Faux Cils mascara for $40 is my Holy Grail! Besides being significantly less expensive, it doesn’t smudge, flake, or leave racoon eyes like the longest lash will do in humidity. Plus, I already use Latisse so don’t need the additional lengthener. It also has the rosewater scent which is divine! I’m always on the look out for something comparable with an even lower price tag, but always end up back with this.

You May Also Like